How to Appeal a Sentence or Conviction in Queensland

Appealing a Sentence or a Conviction.

When you’re faced with a sentence or conviction you believe is unjust, understanding the appeals process is vital. At Valeston Lawyers, we specialise in guiding clients through these complex waters. In this month's blog, we break the process into two major parts: (1) appealing a sentence and (2) appealing a conviction after a trial.

---

1) APPEALING A SENTENCE

If you have pleaded guilty or were found guilty and sentenced, you may still have the option to appeal the penalty imposed by the Judge or Magistrate. This can be a powerful option when you believe the penalty was too harsh or the sentencing judge failed to properly consider key factors.

You can also appeal the sentence if you have had a conviction recorded and where you think no conviction recorded was more appropriate for your circumstance.

When you appeal a sentence, you are only asking the court to reconsider the sentence, not to give you a re-trial or to reverse the plea of guilty. 

Grounds for a Sentence Appeal

In Queensland, you may have grounds to appeal a sentence when:

• The sentence is manifestly excessive – meaning it is clearly disproportionate to the offence, its context or the offender’s circumstances. 
• The court failed to properly consider mitigating factors (for example your background, personal circumstances, remorse, or prospects of rehabilitation). 
• The sentence is inconsistent with comparable cases – for example, similar offences receiving significantly lower penalties.
  

Timeline and Procedure

A Notice of Appeal must normally be lodged within one calendar month of the date of sentencing. An extension of time may be sought in some cases, but you must act quickly and substantiate special reasons why that extension should be granted. 

Depending on which court sentenced you:

• If your sentence was imposed in the Magistrates Court, the appeal may go to the District Court. 
• If your sentence was imposed in the District Court or Supreme Court, the appeal may proceed to the Court of Appeal — but usually only if leave (permission) is granted.

Role of your Appeal Lawyer

Here’s what a specialist appeal lawyer does:

• Conducts a detailed review of the sentencing judgment, transcripts and underlying facts to identify legal or procedural errors, or arguments of manifest excess.
• Prepares and lodges the Notice of Appeal within the strict timeframe.
• Drafts written submissions to the appellate court, explaining why the sentence should be reduced or reconsidered. 
• Represents you at the appeal hearing, arguing your case for a fair outcome.

---

2) APPEALING A CONVICTION AFTER TRIAL

If you have been found guilty at trial, you may have the option to challenge the conviction itself, not just the sentence. This is a more complex and high-stakes appeal, and again time is critical.

Grounds for Conviction Appeal

In Queensland, the grounds on which you can appeal a conviction typically include:

• The evidence did not support the guilty verdict — for example, the evidence was insufficient to sustain the finding of guilt. 
• The judge or magistrate made an error of law (for example misdirection of the jury, incorrect legal principle applied). 
• Improper evidence was admitted (e.g., evidence that should have been excluded) or relevant evidence was ignored/unlawfully rejected. 
• A miscarriage of justice occurred — for example the trial process was unfair or the verdict is clearly unreasonable.

Timeline and Procedure

A Notice of Appeal must normally be lodged within one calendar month of the date of conviction. Extensions of time are rare, so you should seek legal advice as soon as possible if you think you might have grounds. 

Depending on the court in which you were convicted:

• If you were convicted in the Magistrates Court, you may appeal to the District Court. In some cases the appeal may allow fresh evidence. 
• If you were convicted in the District or Supreme Court, your appeal goes to the Court of Appeal, and you may only appeal on points of law (unless special leave is granted for other grounds).

Role of your Appeal Lawyer

When you engage Valeston Lawyers for a conviction appeal:

• We assess your trial transcripts, legal basis of the conviction, and identify potential errors of law or fact.
• We advise on the realistic prospects of success — appeals are challenging and the court does not retry your case from scratch (in most higher court appeals). 
• We prepare the Notice of Appeal and detailed written submissions, highlighting the errors and unfairness at trial.
• We represent you at the appellate hearing, arguing for the conviction to be quashed, your matter retried, or your sentence reconsidered.

---

Why Choose Valeston Lawyers for your Appeal?

​Navigating the appeals system demands specialist expertise. At Valeston Lawyers we combine that expertise with a client-focused approach:

• We have experience dealing with the high stakes of criminal appeals in Brisbane and throughout Queensland.
• We have a panel of exceptional criminal Barristers experienced presenting complex appeals before the District Court and Court of Appeal.
• We offer a free case appraisal, clear communication about your chances of success, and transparency about costs.
• We act swiftly to meet the tight deadlines required for both sentence and conviction appeals.

---

---

Why Choose Valeston Lawyers for your Appeal?

If you’re searching for an appeal lawyer Brisbane, or you’re considering a criminal appeal to challenge a sentence or conviction, or you’re wondering how to appeal a conviction, then swift action and specialist legal advice can make all the difference.

Appeals are not simply a second chance to re-argue your case. They ask the question: Did something go wrong in the process legally, factually or procedurally that affected the outcome? If the answer is yes, then the appeals pathway may provide a route to remedy.

If you believe your sentence was too harsh, or your conviction was unjust, contact us at Valeston Lawyers today for a free case appraisal. Time is of the essence.

---

This blog post is for general information only and is not legal advice.
​For specific advice about your situation, contact Valeston Lawyers today for a free consultation.

Phone 1300 10 30 70  |  Level 10, 95 North Quay, Brisbane, QLD 4000  |  www.valestonlawyers.com.au